Unreasonable Plot Redesigned
🟡 Updated this year⚠️ Install Order · 2 steps
Install in this order, then this mod last — most mods fail to load without their framework and dependencies in place.
Preview

🔍 Analysis
- 👍 0.4% endorsement rate
- 🏆 #7 of 39 Quests and Adventures mods in this game by downloads
📋 About This Mod
Next-Gen 4. 04 Compatible
Redesigned the plot of some quests to make it more reasonable. Currently 12 quests/scenes included:
1. Reason of State:
Everyone already felt that this quest makes no sense when Dijkstra suddenly lost his minds to decide to kill Roche when Geralt is there. I tried my best to make it more reasonable by:
1. Added more followers of Dijkstra to make it more realistic that when you try to kill someone especially a witcher, you will need more hands. Now the starting thugs and the reinforcements are both increased.
2. Added an observer of the conflict who may not leave earlier - Philippa Eilhart. She will hide and see what happens.
3. Now Dijkstra will flee when his health is below 10% or his thugs have been killed more than 10. Which makes sense, when the plan doesn't work as intended, he's clever enough to retreat.
4. But Philippa will take the chance to let him die. She still hates Dijkstra, and if Dijkstra occupies the power of Northen Kingdoms, that will be extremely detrimental to her ambitions for power, besides she already plans to serve the Nilfgaard. So she secretly strikes Dijkstra's legs who is running for his life in weakness with magic, make him can't move but crawling, to prevent him escaping from attacking by Geralt and his friends.
2. Stranger in a Strange Land:
In no way Geralt will be easily kicked down to unconscious as an experienced witcher, just for letting Jorund die? I changed it a little by:
1. Added a bottle under his foot when he's back stepping and parrying for attack so he will stagger, then the thug takes the chance. Now that's the reason why Geralt makes the impossible mistake.
2. Tweaked the scene and the camera, and added the stagger animation to reflect the changes.
3. Gwent: with Lambert:
At Vesemir's funeral.
Geralt loves the old daddy, Lambert won't say it but he loves more. In no way they are mourning in the last minute and suddenly start to laugh and play card games.
Now the option is disabled after the battle, when old daddy died.
As a downside of this modification, you will lose the last opportunity to play with Lambert (yes, at this perfect moment), so you must play with him earlier. But you can always loot the card after Lambert leaves.
4. Gwent: with Baron:
After killing the botchling.
Geralt just killed his daughter...he's so mad and sad...perfect time again!
Now dialogue with Baron is disabled until the Pellar‘s ritual is done.
5. Gwent: with Crach:
After the berserker attack and choosing not to help both his kids.
A slaughter and disaster just happened, and the Craite family has the most suspicion...he definitely has the motion to play Gwent..!
Now dialogue with Crach is disabled until Geralt le
Unreasonable Plot Redesigned is a quest overhaul mod by Freak that revises the storylines of certain quests to make them more logical and coherent. With 511 endorsements and over 125,000 downloads, it has a solid following. Last updated in February 2026, it remains actively maintained. Ideal for players who enjoy narrative improvements over gameplay changes.
✨ Key Features
📊 Pros & Cons
✅ Pros
- Community-approved with 511 endorsements and over 125k downloads.
- Actively maintained—last updated February 2026, so it's likely compatible with current game versions.
- Focused on narrative logic, which is a niche but appreciated improvement for story-driven players.
⚠️ Cons
- May conflict with other quest mods that alter the same quests—no patch info available.
For players who've played through the game multiple times and are bothered by plot holes or illogical quest progressions. If you're a lore enthusiast who wants a more coherent narrative experience, this is worth a shot. Skip if you're looking for new content or gameplay mechanics—this is purely a story tweak.
💡 Beginner Tips
- Check the mod's posts or comments for any reported conflicts with other quest mods before installing.
- Since the description lacks specifics, back up your save or use a mod manager to easily disable it if you don't like the changes.
- If you're using other quest overhauls, load this one after them to ensure its changes take priority.
📊 Mod Details
- Game
- Witcher 3 Mods
- Author
- Freak
- Version
- 2.0b
- Downloads
- 125,676
- Endorsements
- 511
- Category
- Quests and Adventures
- Created
- 12/1/2024
- Updated
- 2/7/2026
🔧 How to Install Witcher 3 Mods
Download from Nexus.
📖 Full step-by-step install guide for Witcher 3 →
Visit the official mod page for specific installation instructions for this mod.
🎮 Need cheat codes or console commands? Check ur gaming wiki for Witcher 3 commands, item IDs, and more.
Keep browsing — more Witcher 3 mods await