Honest Brawls and Finite Response

⭐ ⭐ (999 endorsements) 📥 35,526 downloads 📌 v1.2 📅 9/2/2021
⚪ Last updated 2022

By Goffik · Gameplay

⬇ Download Mod Source: Nexus Mods 📅 Updated: 6/11/2022 📅 Created: 9/2/2021
⚠️ Install Order · 2 steps
1🛠️ Script Hook RDR2 — Script Hook RDR2 Download ↗
2📦 Lenny's Mod Loader Find it →

Install in this order, then this mod last — most mods fail to load without their framework and dependencies in place.

🔍 Analysis

  • 👍 2.8% endorsement rate — high engagement, a strong quality signal
  • 🏆 #61 of 208 Gameplay mods in this game by downloads

📋 About This Mod

Description

This is a pair of mods that I originally made for myself, but I thought others may also enjoy. Each is installed separately so you can use either or both.

Honest Brawls: This makes the act of insulting people, knocking them down, and brawling with them honest and legal. You will no longer be reported for the "crimes" of disturbing the peace or unarmed assault, and you can do both right under the nose of a lawman without fear of any bounty or jail time. (Though you shouldn't do either to the lawman himself, or you will suffer their wrath!)

Finite Response: This makes the law response to your crimes finite, as opposed to infinite. In other words, you will no longer face never-ending waves of lawmen while in the red search radius. If you manage to deal with the initial response, the search will end as if "evaded" and you can continue on your way. There are three different versions to choose from:

  • []Default: You will face local lawmen plus a number of reinforcement waves based on your wanted level.

    []One Wave: You will face local lawmen and just a single wave of reinforcements on horseback.

  • No Reinforcements: You will only face local lawmen. They don't even get support from local residents becoming "deputies".

    Note that this mod does not prevent further witnesses reporting your crimes, triggering a new response. However, wiping out all the local lawmen will make the reporting of crimes rather more difficult for people...

    Installation

    Both mods require Lenny's Mod Loader (LML) to work. You can find it using the following link:

    Lenny's Mod Loader @ RDR2Mods.com

    Compatibility

    These mods will not be compatible with any other mod that changes the same files. Check the mod folders to find out which files these are. Only activate one version of Finite Response at a time.

    Important Note

    It is not feasible for me to test this mod with the game's many story missions. While I don't expect any particular issues, if a mission has triggers reliant on a specific law response then it might break. If you have problems during a specific mission, simply disable the mod, complete the mission, and then re-enable the mod.

    - Honest Brawls: Fixed an issue which allowed unarmed assault to remain a crime in St Denis.

    - Finite Response: Adjusted St Denis law response for "No Reinforcements" and "One Wave" versions.

    - On request, split Finite Response into three different versions.

    - Modified the law response to a number of new areas not included in the initial release.

    - Extended spawn delays in many wilderness areas to facilitate train robberies.

    - Fixed a bug which was preventing crimes from resulting in a wanted level in St Denis.

    - Initial Release.

    You are free to use these mods in any way you please. There is no need to ask my permission or to credit me if you wish to use or modify the files for use in your own projects. My only request is that you do not ask for any kind of donation for mods that include my work. In my humble opinion mods should be free for all without any expectation of monetary reward for those releasing them. It's a hobby after all, not a job.

🤖 AI-enhanced — based on mod data

Honest Brawls and Finite Response is a pair of gameplay mods for Red Dead Redemption 2 that remove bounties for brawling and make law enforcement response finite. Includes three versions of Finite Response to control reinforcement waves. Requires Lenny's Mod Loader.

✨ Key Features

Removes bounties and jail time for disturbing the peace and unarmed assault, allowing legal brawls in front of lawmen.
Finite Response replaces infinite lawmen spawns with a finite number of reinforcements based on wanted level.
Three versions of Finite Response: Default (local lawmen plus reinforcement waves), One Wave (single horseback reinforcement), and No Reinforcements (local lawmen only).
Each mod installs separately, so you can use either or both.
Compatible with other mods as long as they don't change the same files.

📊 Pros & Cons

✅ Pros

  • Community favorite with 999 endorsements and over 35k downloads.
  • Two distinct gameplay tweaks in one package—brawl freely and end the lawman grind.
  • Three Finite Response options let you dial in the challenge exactly how you like it.

⚠️ Cons

  • Requires Lenny's Mod Loader, so you'll need to set that up first.
  • Not compatible with other mods that touch the same files—check before stacking.
  • Only one Finite Response version can be active at a time, so you'll have to pick your favorite.
🎯 Is This For You?
For RDR2 players who hate getting bounties for bar fights and are tired of endless lawman waves during escapes. Also for those who want more control over law enforcement difficulty. Skip if you prefer the vanilla infinite chase or don't want to bother with mod loader setup.
📦 Install:Medium· 5-10 minutes

💡 Beginner Tips

  • Make sure Lenny's Mod Loader is installed and working before adding these mods—they won't run without it.
  • Only activate one version of Finite Response at a time; mixing them will cause conflicts.
  • Check the mod folders to see which files they change, and avoid using other mods that modify the same files.

📊 Mod Details

Game
RDR2 Mods
Author
Goffik
Version
1.2
Downloads
35,526
Endorsements
999
Category
Gameplay
Created
9/2/2021
Updated
6/11/2022

🔧 How to Install RDR2 Mods

Install Script Hook RDR2 first. Most mods go in game directory.

📖 Full step-by-step install guide for RDR2 →

Visit the official mod page for specific installation instructions for this mod.

🎮 Need cheat codes or console commands? Check ur gaming wiki for RDR2 commands, item IDs, and more.

Keep browsing — more RDR2 mods await

📋 All RDR2 Mods 🏆 Top 25 📂 More Gameplay 👤 More by Goffik 🔎 Similar Mods 🌐 Best Gameplay (All Games) 🔀 Check Compatibility ⚖️ Compare Mods 🆕 New Mods